What Are the Best Carbon Arrows for Hunting?

Looking for the best carbon arrows for hunting? It is important for a successful bow hunter to use the best arrows when shooting if they desire optimal performance. The top carbon arrows will perform superiorly, be more consistent, and have elevated levels of precision as opposed to their non-carbon counterparts. Thus, the bow hunter will be significantly more triumphant when hunting.

Carbon arrows, which made their first appearance in the hunting scene in the early 1990s, are undoubtedly the most well-liked type of arrows being used today. Carbon arrows weigh less and can withstand more and with better straightness than even aluminum arrows, ensuing in faster speeds, better precision, and deeper penetration. The very best carbon arrows are marketed to have tolerances for straightness from 0.001 to 0.006 inches. Unsurprisingly, carbon arrows are pricier the straighter they are, but it is no surprise why these arrows have quickly become the most popular amongst bow hunters.

Manufacturers vigilantly evaluate each arrow as it comes off the manufacturing line, and the arrows are subsequently divided into ranks founded on their straightness.  Carbon arrows are categorized by this straightness, with the finest arrows being in the 0.001-0.002” range, mid-range arrows falling within 0.003-0.004”, and average carbon arrows being at 0.005-0.006”. All levels of straightness work beautifully, but the straighter the arrow, the straighter the shot.

Taking such information into consideration, five of the best rated carbon arrows have been compiled and listed below.

  • Carbon Express PileDriver
  • Rating: 4.7/5
  • straightness tolerance 0.0004″
  • weight tolerance 2.0 grains
  • must be cut to length
  • Price: $
  • Beman ICS Bowhunter
  • Rating: 5/5
  • straightness tolerance 0.0006″
  • weight tolerance 2.0 grains
  • must be cut to length
  • Price: $$
  • Carbon Express Maxima Red
  • Rating: 4.5/5
  • straightness tolerance 0.0025″
  • weight tolerance
  • must be cut to length
  • Price: $$
  • Gold Tip XT Hunter
  • Rating: 4.8/5
  • straightness tolerance 0.003″
  • weight tolerance
  • must be cut to length
  • Price: $$$
  • Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak
  • Rating: 4.4/5
  • straightness tolerance 0.0025″
  • weight tolerance 1 grain
  • must be cut to length
  • Price: $$$
Carbon Express PileDriverBeman ICS BowhunterCarbon Express Maxima RedGold Tip XT HunterCarbon Express Maxima Blue Streak
Rating: 4.7/5Rating: 5/5Rating: 4.5/5Rating: 4.8/5Rating: 4.4/5
straightness tolerance 0.0004″straightness tolerance 0.0006″straightness tolerance 0.0025″straightness tolerance 0.003″ straightness tolerance 0.0025″
weight tolerance 2.0 grainsweight tolerance 2.0 grainsweight tolerance weight tolerance weight tolerance 1 grain
must be cut to lengthmust be cut to lengthmust be cut to lengthmust be cut to length must be cut to length
Price: $Price: $$Price: $$Price: $$$Price: $$$

1.) Carbon Express PileDriver

carbon-express-piledriverThe Carbon Express PileDriver is the heaviest arrow created by Carbon Express, which produces maximum kinetic energy. This is great for bow hunters who want to convey more impactful blows with ultimate penetration into their target from further distances.

Furthermore, in order to create tighter groupings, the PileDriver carbon arrows are equipped with a technology known as “weight-forward.” The sophisticated production of these arrows guarantees spine stability for better precision falling in at 0.004 inches for straightness. The shafts will need to be cut to length, as well as inserts glued in by the bow hunter.

Overall, this is a great arrow at its price point and grade-level for bow hunters wanting an effective hunt.

2.) Beman ICS Bowhunter

beman-ics-bowhunterIf you are looking for a great mid-range carbon hunting arrow at an inexpensive price, Beman ICS Bowhunter arrows are what you are looking for. You will receive twelve carbon hunting arrows for the cost of six premium arrows, without giving up too much in execution.

The shafts will need to be cut to length and the Easton inserts that come provided glued in upon arrival with these 32” long arrows. Bright yellow Easton nocks come all ready assembled onto the arrows.

The shaft straightness tolerance of the ICS Bowhunters is 0.006 inches.  That is not quite what you would receive with a premium carbon arrow, but it is decent precision with forceful impact and still gets the job done, especially for the price.

3.) Carbon Express Maxima Red

carbon-express-maxima-redThe Carbon Express Maxima Red carbon arrows are viewed as one of the best hunting arrows produced by Carbon Express. The carbon arrows are created with a high-tech design, purposely intended at providing superior broadhead precision and performance. Such a design is attained by having the dynamic in-flight flexing spine contained within the stiff ends of the arrow.

Only two different spine sizes are necessary to meet the draw weights from 40 to 81 pounds due to how proficiently controlled the dynamic spine is. The straightness of the shaft is measured via laser and separated to a tolerance zone of 0.0025 inches.

The Maxima Red carbon arrows also are equipped with Launchpad nocks, BullDog collars, and Blazer vanes. The Maxima Red is a fantastic carbon arrow that provides great quality and imparts a steady weight for hunting.

4.) Gold Tip XT Hunter

gold-tip-xt-hunterThe XT Hunter is the best selling carbon hunting arrow manufactured by Gold Tip, with the 5575 Blacks being the most liked size with bow hunters. The XT’s are recognized as being very dependable and able to easily survive practice sessions as well as maintain and withstand deer hunting season due to their sturdiness.

The XT Hunter’s are sorted by hand and laser inspected to have a shaft tolerance of 0.003 inches. You must cut the shafts to your chosen shooting length on these carbon arrows and glue the inserts that come with them, but they do come with pre-fixed with 2” Blazer vanes. The XT Hunter is a great, durable, precise carbon arrow.

5.) Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak

carbon-express-maxima-blue-streakCarbon Express’s lightest carbon hunting arrows are the Maxima Blue Streaks. They offer extreme velocity with great accuracy and precision. The Maxima Blue Streak arrow shafts are created with Diamond Weave, which is a durable cross-weaved carbon substance. The carbon weave produces an arrow that has fantastic spine stability as well as being remarkably stiff.

These carbon arrows have a straightness tolerance of 0.0025 inches, and a weight tolerance of 1 grain. These carbon arrows come equipped with Carbon Express special Launchpad nocks with BullDog collars to shield direct blows to the ends. The Blue Streaks must be cut by the bow hunter to the desired length, but they are pre-fletched with white and blue Blazer vanes.

This reasonably priced carbon hunting arrow is a great, precise, durable choice that is outfitted with top features.

There you have it, the best carbon arrows for hunting. Make sure you check out our most comfortable climbing tree stands.